It all depends. We both agree that in terms of last gen and the $300 price point the S is king. You say that the Ps5 DE is a better proposition for the extra money and I agree in some cases. But what if I was an xbox 360 owner and still have a bunch of the games , xbox one owner with a bunch of games ? Both ? The ps5 doesn't play any of those games while the series s will play any of the ones I have digital. If i was a large physical purchaser then the $200 for the series x would be the best purchase.
Then there is another scenario which is a person limited on space the ps5 is gigantic compared to the S. Right now for me that doesn't matter I have plenty of space. But I remember how big the dorms my friends had or some of our first apartments. I also know people who move from one place to another and would want a much smaller and lighter console
View attachment 5499
Aside from that I would wager for people who have $400 or $500 to spend the xbox series x and ps5 in both formats are better purchases . The xbox series x gets you twice the storage capacity , the ultra hd bluray drive and a much more powerful and capable machine while still having access to all of microsofts services like game pass. The ps5 de would get you into the sony eco system . The disc drive one would allow you to access the ps4 library dirt cheap with used games.
I would actually tell a person who had $300 now to spend on a console to just do a series x all access. Its $35 a month and you get the x and game pass ultimate . Payments are 2 years so your paying $840. Of course its a lot more than a $300 system sure. But you get access to hundreds of games off the bat plus xbox live. That $300 you had saved will get you what 8 months of payments towards the system. So during that 8 months you can put more money on the side to continue payments or that $35 may be money you can easily put together each month.
Same if someone was going to buy a used ps4 or xbox one . The S is $25 a month via all access. You'll spend $600 over the two years but of course you get game pass ultimate. The initial money you'd spend. Heck on gamestop it appears the PS4 slim black is $280 used ! Wow the xbox one phat is $240. Yea def I would say do all access on the s or x over any last gen console