Johnny Awesome said:
I don't hate Sony at all. I might even pick up a PS3 late in the console cycle. I just don't like the spread of misinformation. As much as you consider it Sony's right to lie. I consider it my right to call them out for doing so. Sony has lied like crazy to investors and consumers. That's all I'm saying and it's the truth. I'm not saying that Sony is doomed or that no one should get a PS3. I'm sure it will be a powerful system with compelling games.
I think you and I have different estimations of what the word 'lie' means.
If you say you are going to the grocery store to get some fruit, but you're in an accident along the way and don't make it, did you 'lie' to me?
Sony has never said anything that I would construe as an egregious 'lie.' One would have to be on a different planet entirely to let themselves get wrapped up in 'Toy Story' and 'Matrix' and '4D' claims of hyperbole. Because hyperbole is all it is.
Sony
has fallen short on expectations before, this I grant. But I don't think it was for reasons based in deception in their origination, simply a change of circumstance that warranted a - rightful - shift of direction.
I'm willing to have a serious discussion about the ways in which Sony has fallen short of set expectations in the past (though perhaps this thread is not the best venue for such) - but I am unwilling to have a discussion based around the concept of corporate lying.
This isn't some pro-Sony stance of mine either per se, I really think you have to cross a line to warrant the 'lie' accusation in business. Enron, MCI, that sort of level. Microsoft, Wal-Mart, I'll defend all the corporate 'bad guys' for whom I feel information is readily available to the extent that the onus is on the consumer to educate themselves.
PS - I
hate extensive lobbying actions and the whole government/business tie-ins by the way, since I'm talking about big business, it's just that a lot of this malfeasance - as dirty as it is - is honestly overt in nature. I'm pro maximum accountability, but even beyond that, maximum citizen/consumer self education.
PPS - If you don't like KK, I don't even have an issue with that. It's just why drag that into this thread, which is really a celebration of so much waiting on some of our parts? This thread isn't 'serious' in nature IMO, it's more of a stress release. Believe me the debate threads will come as the monthe/weeks/days go by.