Fair enough I suppose though it didn't make a lot of sense to me. Rosberg came in right behind Hamilton with a faster time, but missed the final lap while Hamilton got another. I don't know why Alonso and Kimi were so far behind both at the end.
No matter how fanboy one is or isn't, no-one can claim the decision by stewards was wrong, he gained advantage by cutting corner and never really gave it up
Obviously not.
Sorry, I was away for a few weeks and missed this one. Let me get it right - the only fair thing would have been if Kimi was rewarded the win right, because he only lost it because of Lewis's illegal pass... right? I'm sure that's something you of all people would agree with
It's irrelevant what would have or wouldn't have happened, no-one can know what would have happened if Hamilton hadn't passed Kimi with the advantage he gained. Maybe neither would have had to go off-line or even off-track, maybe both would have crashed, maybe aliens would have attacked the race, who knows, but it's still irrelevant.Hamilton was always going to pass Kimi once the track conditions had changed - he closed the gap and was clearly quicker - if not this corner, he would have passed him later for sure. The fact that Kimi later crashed made the whole move redundant as he wouldn't have won anyway. (well if he hadn't been passed, perhaps he wouldn't have crashed, but he did crash all by himself). The whole FIA decision smelled of race-fixing.
Yes, it could have been handled better, but it still went by the book in the end.Even if the move wasn't entirely fair on paper (which no one is arguing) - it was accoarding to the rules and they clarified that with Charlie who thought the same. Even if Charlie is not "the stewards" - he does have some authority as the race-director which is why teams constantly ask for his input in such conditions. The stewarding system was openly criticed again and again througout that year and especially after this race. In the end, this whole thing could have been handled much better.
Can we please keep pointless discussions about 2008 out of this thread?
All we need is one dnf from vettel and its game on. I wouldn't write the season off yet but it's almost his you are right
The problem isn't so much Alonso or Hamilton needing to win 2 races with Vettel scoring no points. That can happen. The problem is that needs to happen and then Alonso or Hamilton need to beat Vettel consistently afterwards. The chances of both these things happening are beginning to vanish pretty rapidly.