Car game comparisons *hit & run*
- Thread starter Technewsreader
- Start date
Dude you are the one taking it out of proportions.
It is a given that more powerful hardware will produce better results. Was there a doubt really that X would produce significant enhancements compared to any other console?
What is your problem if a game achieves something unique in less powerful hardware and someone points it out?
You give the impression that you are more annoyed by your assumption that people have some secret agenda to question Forza 7's ultimate superiority and achievement than trying to see where someone is trully coming from
Yes Forza 7 is better looking overall. That doesnt take away from what Drive Club achieves better though regardless what game pushes which console the most.
The funny thing about racers comparisons is that nobody is actually trying to decide between buying F7 , or GTS, or Mario Kart.
Because everyone is comparing Mario Karts.
Fixed
Are you serious, FH3 ? Look how they do clouds in FH3, they have their own 2D morphing tech.
Xbox One X, 6 TFlops of power to better morph 2D textures in true™ 4K.
Clearly inferior in F7, especially the dynamic weather (not even comparable in my opinion).
By the way, i just realized this amazing video was made by Vspectra... one of the best video ever made on DriveClub and the music is nice.
It's the Xbox one version though. Maybe better on X, i don't know...
Last edited:
Maybe but F7 has to push 8 times more pixels per second than Driveclub... it's a very large difference...
Also, high end GPU are built to run games at 4k and tend to have lower performances at 1080p (comparatively).
Edit : http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-2016-nvidia-geforce-gtx-1070-review
The game you mentioned seem to be an exception rather than the rule... there is probably a CPU bottleneck.
For instance, Crysis 3 is more than 3 times faster at 1080p than 4k with a 1070. Also, on console, performances tend to scale pretty well with GPU power and PC don't have unified memory.
Last edited:
It's the Xbox one version though. Maybe better on X, i don't know...
It must be an AI car zoomed up in photo mode, keep in mind that forza 7 is 60fps with up to 24 cars on track.
In driveclub's photo mode if you slowly zoom on AI cars you can see a LOD switch.
Don’t give a flying f...k about 2d clouds . The game looks jaw dropping on the Xbox one and I can’t wait to see it on the Xbox one x. It kills the sterile, blurry look of drive club which has become a champion of some people for obvious reasons. I could post tons of gameplay videos showing the glory of FH3 but what would be the point ?
I understand what you are saying but I didnt raise Drive Club as an absolute comparison against Forza. I was highlighting Drive Club's underlying tech, the unique features of the engine if you will.
Of course it is even pointless to compare the X version with PS4. 8 times more pixels on more powerful hardware? It is a given that more powerful hardware will have the extra juice to push things farther and beyond on like for like senarios.
What is achieved on S can be a better appreciation of what T10 has achieved, because thats a game running at double the framerate (and at1080p) on hardware comparable (and less powerful) than PS4 and all that with a superb dynamic weather.
In that case you can appreciate Turn 10's superb achievement at making a 60fps racer on vanilla hardware that has super detailed environments and dynamic weather, where games like PC2 and GTS demonstrate cut backs to achieve 60fps.
And on the other case you can appreciate Drive Club's superbly advanced weather and physics system that has a very unique approach.
There is a photomode in the demo?
This is not what i said. My point is : Evolution had more compute power per pixel than Turn 10 on X. This is why DriveClub still looks better if we exclude the IQ.
Technically, F7 on X is far more impressive but it's obvious considering the hardware difference.
FH3 has a much better IQ, but the lighting still looks flat compared to Driveclub...
But i can understand your preference, FH3 is one of the best looking Xbox One game.
But I dont really have a preference
I don't believe in witch hunting, or post history recalls, it can be entirely in my error in reading (or inferring, or mixing up) posts that would suggest you were on the side that a 1080p DC was better looking than 1X F7. So in advance, I apologize for indirectly blasting you.
Normally I don't pay attention to this type of thing, but after a while, for the 5th time on this forum, we have comparison posts of Forza vs exclusive on Sony and frankly, as much as I know to stay out of it because it leads down a shitty path for everyone, it's hard to ignore when something is that off.
There should be no doubt that F7 with the higher improvements provided by the hardware of the X would create better results. And you can see in this thread, many have tried to downplay that. Which is ridiculous, but also more ridiculous that the idea that we could compare a game that barely has any footage outside of it's E3 footage, and a released demo which was played at E3, thinking this was enough content to rate the visual prowess and artistic content that all of F7 is capable of. Frankly speaking, the video I posted above, is actually some of the newest footage we've ever seen of Forza outside of the demos.
I don't, and i like drive club. I like what it brings to the table. I like most racing games, I grew up playing GT at my friends places. And Forza didn't become a thing for me until around F5. So I generally like playing sim racers. I have a problem with the method of comparison, it in itself is an agenda for console wars. Because as MrFox writes, every comparison thread, or video is not about buying the products that are being compared. It never has been, Xbox players can't buy DC or GTS, or Mario Kart. There's no point to the comparison expect for owners of the console of their desired title to feel good about themselves.
See above, and I apologize for blasting you, for either mixing up or whatever the case. If you want to talk about DriveClubs great merits when it comes to weather and physics, we can make a thread about it, and just discuss how technically cool it is. No one here has an issue with that, but when you try to cross compare it with other titles and flat out general statements come out without looking at the overall picture (of an unfinished game)... it comes off as not interested in being impartial or interested in the actual compare or discussion of the technologies at play.
As I said earlier, it's entirely possible I read/mixed up your commentary wrong up to this point. But after F7 comes out, this rodeo will happen again. And next year, it will happen again with the next Forza game. And the year after, after. It happens all the time.
And this is where we get into the off-topic discussion of things that I don't want to discuss.
