Well, now, I wouldn't say he's out there for flamebait.
From a more general perspective... we haven't really seen anything that great. Games like Tengai Makyou or Super Robot Taisen may have me really excited, but I can recognize that they're more cult favorites rather than mainstream, especially from a western view.
And, while PGR may look great we kinda already knew this from bizarre's website.
Frame City Killer (was killer dropped from the title?) is kinda borederline -- some are impressed some aren't.
What we need to see are some enchant arm trailers, some winning eleven, some ridge racer and so forth stuff to get the more mainstream gamers attention. Big names, you know. We haven't really seen anything new in that sense. Granted, in part, that's because the media has been kinda slow to trickle out... I don't think he's too off for saying it. If you go through the Japanese news sites there only a few blurbs here and there about a few games, mostly it's just a copy of the games list.
If MS is smart they'll do the same thing they did with the E3 trailers and host them in HD on their website. That'll get some buzz going... seeing is believing, after all.
EDIT:: Speak of the devil... Namco's Love Football.
http://xboxyde.com/leech_1523_en.html