The other weird thing is, GS trashes the cutscenes, but from what I've seen of the cutscenes in downloadable movies, they look better graphically than most other console FPS games: normal "polybump" mapping, environment mapping, self shadowing, etc I don't think the textures will loook as good as a PC, but they look pretty darn good for a game that runs smooth on a GF3 and a half equivalent 700Mhz celery.
Other reviewers said H2 has no repetitive levels like H1 library level, so I don't quite get GS's comments on this. Only two things mentioned everywhere that people agree on: short campaign and disappointing cliffhanger ending.
That said, I've heard HL2 has somewhat of a cliffhanger ending too.