Silent_Buddha
Legend
When Gears launched, it was a fairly stand-out gritty sci-fi shooter with a rather novel cover mechanic. Now sci-fi shooters are ten a penny, it's just one of a crowd that doesn't have an obvious USP (I don't think the story is enough of a draw for most gamers with this IP). A sequel will probably need to reinvent the brand, but one has to question the value of reusing a brand name that consumers have shown they are tired of. I suppose a next-gen Gears shooter would have some immediate recognition and a comfortable ~million sales to ensure it breaks even, whereas a new IP might fail to gain interest entirely and bomb. But I'd be more inclined to try something new and look for a new hook if I were MS, preferably something that utilises the unique features of the system.
Along those lines, if I were MS and Titanfall has a Gears of War level of success on the platform, I'd throw a lot of money at Respawn and EA in an attempt to keep it platform specific.
Out of all the new IP being shown, it has the greatest chance to replicate the success of Gears, IMO.
But if it has COD levels of success, then that might be virtually impossible.
Regards,
SB