Some developer comments on PS3/X360 (Edge Magazine)

Status
Not open for further replies.
hasanahmad said:
This is precisely the reason why i made the thread "why the nitpicking of proving PS3 is much more powerful than Xbox 360"

I thought a user called "gosh" made the "why the nitpicking of proving PS3 is much more powerful than Xbox 360" thread?

Do you have two accounts? One for the case if you get banned?! :LOL:
 
gosh is an account on bugmenot.com which 3-4 people use when i dont feel like signing in. this is my real account. dont talk rubbish
 
HellFire_ said:
hasanahmad said:
This is precisely the reason why i made the thread "why the nitpicking of proving PS3 is much more powerful than Xbox 360"

I thought a user called "gosh" made the "why the nitpicking of proving PS3 is much more powerful than Xbox 360" thread?

Do you have two accounts? One for the case if you get banned?! :LOL:

the gosh account is posted on bugmenot.com
 
hasanahmad said:
i think GT5 and MGS4 will be launch titles, if thier so far ahead PS3 will lose steam

Kazunori yamuch, and hideo kojima arent like developers of PGR3 or ghost recon3...they take their time for developing their games, and they dont give a shit for sony telling them : we want those games at launch !
those are kazunori yamuchi and kojima, not anyone...

we will see if bungie will refuse or not to launch an incomplete halo3 when ps3 launch...wait and see...
 
hasanahmad said:
the developer of GT5 took his time and got beaten by Forza which took half the time to complete

Oh really ? How ?
Forza is better than GT4 ?
better gameplay ?!
more cars ?!
more and better tracks ?!
a far better AI ?!
...

OK I see...
 
fouad said:
hasanahmad said:
the developer of GT5 took his time and got beaten by Forza which took half the time to complete

Oh really ? How ?
Forza is better than GT4 ?
better gameplay ?!
more cars ?!
more and better tracks ?!
a far better AI ?!
...

OK I see...

better gameplay
lesser cars
equally better tracks
harder AI
better reviews on gamerankings.com
 
hasanahmad said:
Tatiano, a 4x 6800 would mean its TFLOP rating is not 1.8 Tflop but 3.6 Tflop

2x 6800 in SLI != 4x 6800

Hardknock said:
I find this weird. Why didn't you post any positive quotes about Xbox 360, or negative quotes for PS3?? BTW for those that don't know, Titanio/Gofreak is a known Sony whore.

There is a lot I did not post. For example, there's an NVidia interview in there which I didn't touch. There's ATi comments too which I did not post. There's a lot of editorial in there too which I did not touch. I simply stuck to including what the devs and tools companies were quoted as saying because I felt they should be the ones who know what they're talking about and they're the ones who should be independent. To quote the whole interviews would take far too much time. I included the parts I thought were more interesting, and I tried to mix it between PS3 and X360 (and there are positive things said in those comments about X360!)

There are positive things said about MS/X360 elsewhere, but a lot of it focusses around strategy rather than technical matters which is what I was concerned with posting here (Mark Rein is quite positive on MS's approach so far, and sympathises with their dev kit predicament at E3, for example). But there are also more other positive things said about PS3 that I didn't post too.

However I can't say that anyone suggests X360 is more powerful than PS3 in the same way as the oppostive is suggested in the quotes above, except ATi. But then NVidia says the opposite, and as above I didn't think it fair to include either of their comments. I'm afraid I can't magic up those comments to make this seem fairer for you.
 
Titanio said:
hasanahmad said:
Tatiano, a 4x 6800 would mean its TFLOP rating is not 1.8 Tflop but 3.6 Tflop

2x 6800 in SLI != 4x 6800

Hardknock said:
I find this weird. Why didn't you post any positive quotes about Xbox 360, or negative quotes for PS3?? BTW for those that don't know, Titanio/Gofreak is a known Sony whore.

There is a lot I did not post. For example, there's an NVidia interview in there which I didn't touch. There's ATi comments too which I did not post. There's a lot of editorial in there too which I did not touch. I simply stuck to including what the devs and tools companies were quoted as saying. To quote the whole interviews would take far too much time. I included the parts I thought were more interesting.

There are positive things said about MS/X360, but a lot of it focusses around strategy rather than technical matters (Mark Rein is quite positive on MS's approach so far, and sympathises with their dev kit predicament at E3, for example).

However I can't say that anyone suggests X360 is more powerful than PS3 in the same way as in the quotes above, except ATi. But then NVidia says the opposite, and I didn't think it fair to include either of their comments. I'm afraid I can't magic up those comments to make this seem fairer for you.

yes the Cell is slightly more powerful than the Xbox cpu but the GPU in Xbox is better than the Rsx
 
hasanahmad said:
yes the Cell is slightly more powerful than the Xbox cpu but the GPU in Xbox is better than the Rsx

What are you even responding to? Go tell it to these people if you're unhappy about it :rolleyes:

(And I would disagree with what you're saying, but that's irrelevant)
 
Titanio said:
hasanahmad said:
yes the Cell is slightly more powerful than the Xbox cpu but the GPU in Xbox is better than the Rsx

What are you even responding to? Go tell it to these people if you're unhappy about it :rolleyes:

(And I would disagree with what you're saying, but that's irrelevant)


so you are telling me the RSX is more powerful than the ATI GPU on xbox 360
 
Hardknock said:
I find this weird. Why didn't you post any positive quotes about Xbox 360, or negative quotes for PS3?? BTW for those that don't know, Titanio/Gofreak is a known Sony whore.
Let's keep the discussion civil, and forget about ad hominem arguments too.

If you think the poster didn't post everything worth posting about this Edge article, because of some evil hidden agenda, then, first, ask the poster why, if there's anything else interesting to post, he didn't post it.
After that, if the answer doesn't sound good to you, you are free to disregard or discuss his opinions and posts on the subject.
 
Hardknock said:
I hate people spreading misinformation. The RSX is not the equal to 4x 6800. That's ridiculous. :rolleyes: It was stated by Sony themselves, that the 6800 SLi setup at E3 was 75% of the power of the final PS3.

Cell clock speedy was 75% of the final clock speed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top