Not the review. The review is very well written and detailed. Carolyn is an excellent writer. The comments are what's sad (at least I hope he's referring to the comments). Actually, calling the reactions sad is really putting it lightly.
Ok I see now, just got caught up to all the hubbub.
All I have to say about that is it's not surprising. Had it happen with U2, had it happen with TLoU, and of course it would with GTA5. Crazy reactions to slightly lower review scores I mean. I guess it's a good thing I usually can't read the comments on these sites anyways because of noscript.
Yeah, the comments are what I'm talking about. An overwhelmingly positive review, with a very good score given, and the cretinous hoard arrive because it didn't get 10/10. Not surprising as you say but, ya know, it would be nice to be pleasantly surprised now and again. The nature of a lot of the comments against the reviewer are particularly obnoxious in this case as well.