RancidLunchmeat
Veteran
90% of gamers will defend their purchases no matter how much it sucks, especially on the internet. Go to the Lair or Golden Axe: Beast Rider message boards on gamefaqs and they'll tell you how awesome the game is and that you should buy it. It's the same with every game too.
I actually find that type of behavior seldom applies to small purchases or impulse buys. It's usually the large purchases that people will deflect their feelings of buyers remorse by trying to convince themselves and everybody else that the purchase was actually a great one.
A menial $60 purchase? Not so much influenced. Especially not when the trade in value of the game is so high right now due to supply shortages. They could just dump the game and move on.
After reading the 'official' reviews and reading the 'players' reviews online, I really get the feeling the harsh reviews are mainly due to two factors 1) Many reviews flat out stated the zombie genre is overplayed in their opinion and 2) Many reviewers thought the game was going to be a survival horror game ala the original resident evil series, rather than a L4D/Borderlands mash-up.
Again, I haven't played it. I might go buy it today and play it this weekend, if I do, I'll let you know if the problems are real or imagined. Then again, as a huge L4D fan and an even larger Borderlands fan, I'll probably either love it or hate it due to my expectations as well!