That whole discussion with Shifty came about in another thread comparing the cost of pc gaming to console gaming. I was saying that to compare true costs you needed to buy both old and new consoles to play the popular games, and buy an extra controller for the old and for the new console because the console controllers were not compatible across generations, something not needed on pc since a single 360 controller could play old gen and new gen games. Looks like that spilled into this thread, but I'll leave it at that.
Yeah, way back we all called it the ps3 tax, because for whatever bizarre reason Sony didn't go with a removable battery even though most everything else they sell has a removable battery, hence you were basically required to get a second ps3 controller so we all got one for when the battery died unexpectedly. I resisted at first until the battery died in the middle of playing Warhawk online, after which I broke down and bought a second ps3 controller basically as a battery, and naturally got mocked by my co-workers in the process. Sounds like they did the same thing for ps4 controllers? I guess not really surprising, since people don't seem to include that sort of thing in the true costs of the platform, hence Sony may as well use it as an extra revenue source since you basically have to buy an extra controller unless you are content gaming 80's style with a 15 foot cord.
I wasn't trying to correct, just make a point
As for the rechargeable battery pack, Fuck that. I am so tired of my 360 controllers crappy battery system. Even the one with a actual official Microsoft rechargeable battery pack is crap, it doesn't charge anymore, and the one that runs on normal battery had a battery leak, welcome to the freaking 90s.
I often have to take the corded 360 controllers and plug in to the 360 when the kids wants to play minecraft.
As for the ps3, if people are able to keep their mobile phone charged, then it shouldn't be a challenge to keep your controllers juiced up. I can see others have different feelings about this, but that is one of those things that I have a very hard time*. And this is based 100% on actual experience with the different controllers. Damn I get angry thinking about the xb1 ridiculous battery solution.. grrr