Good presentation by Sony. They couldn't resist pulling out the facts and figures, though. I have seen stated that these belong in a keynote, but I disagree. They can just as easily be disseminated in an accompanying press release and be added in to the reports the media write about the event after the fact.
Also the video montages with games flashing by so fast you barely have time to recognize them, never mind make any determinations of how interesting they look have got to go. Much favored MS's approach in giving fewer games more focus instead and would like to see this replicated (haven't seen Nintendo's keynote yet).
Is anyone else with me in thinking that most of the live gameplay demonstrations could be replaced with the developers coming out to talk over a pre-recorded gameplay segment? This would allow them to better prepare their remarks and create a more compelling demo. Allowing the game to then be live demo'd to the press later so they can vouch for the credibility of the demo would prevent any shenanigans. The exceptions to this would be games like Rock Band or games with motion controls where the player themself is actually doing something visually interesting and presents part of the appeal of the title.
More specifically to Sony, I thought Tretton was good. He appeared confident, but not arrogant as he has in the past.
I found PSP Go! to be really appealing, right up until the price announcement. An $80 premium over the PSP-3000? Really? Any additional draw to the platform that the new form factor was going to provide has been neutered by that price IMO. I'm also kind of torn about the types of titles they are pushing. While the power of the machine allows for game experiences that are unique to the platform in the mobile space, the broader market has not really shown an appetite for these experiences in the past (at least the ones who are willing to pay). It is questionable whether Sony will be able to expand their userbase by focusing on these types of experiences. But then again, the alternative may alienate their existing user base and still not allow them to attract the broader market, which would be disastrous.
MAG looked interesting. Seeing a live engagement really brought homw what the game is supposed to be in a way that hadn't been possible before. It gave of an MMO massive raid/pvp vibe that could definately work for it.
FFXIV? Exclusive to PS3?! 2010??!! Online.... Oh.
GT5 looked good (of course) what little we saw of it. I'm personally most hyped about the WRC license, though I think the NASCAR license will help more when they market this game in the US. Still no release date, though? Not even a 2010? Honestly, not too bad for me because a PS3 purchase isn't going to happen for me any time soon and F3 is coming in October. But WTH for people who have actually been awaiting this game since GT4? Feature creep? Mandate from Sony to shift focus to GT PSP at the expense of GT5's development? Saving the release date reveal for one of the other trade shows?
Edit: Thanks for moving my post to where it belongs. In return, I'll move my motion controller comments where they belong.