The big big big flaw of FF games is the character art, yes
The Tecmo Dolls!! That turn many off, as the mindset of the more realistic, the better able to feel the ph33r. Im sure if Tecmo take out the girls of FF and replace them with Heather and do the quality cutscenes, FF can reach out to a wider audience.
BUT
ImhO, that do nuts for me, dolls or real. Games are games and they stay games. I dunno, i don see myself INTO the games, but just playing ALONG with it. MayB i ain imaginative enuFF to think of myself INTO Silent Hill but well it is still a game to me. Heather as realistically modelled, still looking like Polygon Girl to me.
The OTHER thing is, the rotting rusty hellish places/enemies of SH seem to struck a cord better than the haunted ghostly villages of FF, with many. A grisly environment may gross people out, but well the whole thing still look like a game to me. ie NOT real enough to recreate real gross stuff to turn the stomach
ImhO. Nothing wrongy, since no console/PC can do that today. So putting the game lead into such places, ALONE, is not enough for me. There has to be something else to heighten the frights. AND there is where the unpredicable evil ghosts of FF come in. Add the salt seaoning to the final dishes! YummY! SH monsters as "grisly looking"(ie NOT) as they are, are more like pale flour. Tasteless and useless, to do nothing to make it YummY.
AND, NO. FF has as good ATMOSPHERE as SH. I
PERSONALLY like the haunted Japanese village of FF more, Japanese scares alway seem the creepier creeps to me. The audio quality is great too. NO complains about both.
So it is NOT an ATMOSPHERE thing
ImhO. The whole thingy is down to the VISUAL SETTINGS of the 2 games. The "cleaner"/"animey" like settings of FF are not likey to be love by some i guess.
OH HO! The last thing, it too be like Tecmo arent likey to be associated with tEh cool games with PS2 crowd, unlike say, Konami. NOT they hatey Tecmo(mayB, mayB not) but some are more likey to look toward a Konami games than Tecmo, for some (un?)-known reasons.
" OH HO! What? Konami announces a new game? Gotta check it out when its out! OH HO! Tecmo new game? Hmmm....i be waiting to see if i spot that in the bargain basement. "
WoW! That be long post man! I hope i get the points across.
Games are still games, they be likey by some, not likey by others. Hope people give FF a chance, even tho the game may look "kiddy" compare to SH.