Sigfried1977
Legend
50 bucks is a lot harder to swallow than 10 bucks. People don't go and see 5 movies in a row. (just as they usually don't buy 5 indie games for 10 bucks a pop all at once)
The Order: 1886
- Thread starter Bagel seed
- Start date
-
- Tags
- tig:theorder1886
L. Scofield
Veteran
What choices can you make in TO?
(sorry if this is going off topic)
I think it happens more often than we realize. The discussion reappear whenever a game has a large amount of gamers who loved it, even if the "average" is similar between critics and gamers.
Ryse was more like 1886 in it's focus on graphics (but with multiplayer): gamers >> critics
Metacritic: 8 positive, 60 mixed, 9 negative
User Rating: 242 positive, 25 mixed, 68 negative
Knack was sub-par in terms of graphics, old school in terms of gameplay. gamers >> critics
Metacritic: 9 positive, 46 mixed, 28 negative
User Rating: 165 positive, 27 mixed, 38 negative
1886 is nowhere near the discrepancy of the above two games: gamers == critics
Metacritic: 28 positive, 36 mixed, 7 negative
User Rating: 327 positive, 39 mixed, 103 negative
Neither is Driveclub: gamers < critics
Metacritic: 45 positive, 38 mixed, 1 negative
User Rating: 171 positive, 35 mixed, 110 negative
All four games have a healthy pool of gamers who loved it, despite a mixed average.
What matters for sales, is the percentage of gamers who liked it enough to be satisfied with their purchase (and will buy the sequel, or the next game from that studio). Mixed reviews, or mixed gamers reception, is a completely different thing when everybody thought it was only an average game, versus 50% loved it and 50% hated it.
no, you'd likely lose £10-20 depending how much you pay & sell for, still not bad value for at least 9 hours entertainment
I understand that, but as I said, there's ways to make it cheaper
Look over substance and Drive Club? Are you kidding me? The game is full of single player content and when they were reviewing the game the online component worked well. The core gameplay is good...
And The Order 1886 is not so short when you play the first run on hard 10/11 hours for me. I think it miss a harder level of difficulty.
I like The Order 1886 but there are many flaws. Drive Club as a pure simcade racer is very good. At launch it was not so good because of online component. Now it is very good not excellent because replay and private lobbies are missing...
But in 2 to 3 months when the game will be feature complete it will be a blast and being one of the best game of current gen...
Last edited:
Because you use user review as a metric on metacritic. Between the fanboy of each side and the astroturfing I don't think it is a relevant metric at all...
RenegadeRocks
Legend
What shooting/fighting can u do in HR? C'mon.
L. Scofield
Veteran
You said TO has the same mechanics than HR and Beyond. Choice is one of the main mechanics lacking in TO compared with those games.
Exactly and whats the point comparing it to other games. The only metric I use for rating a game is did I enjoy it and so far I'm loving the Order 1886 cool story, very cool characters and satisfying gunplay. I have also put about nine to ten hours into it and I'm on chapter twelve. Playing on hard without auto aim and I read the newspapers
RAD Why no zoom feature for the newspapers I have to get real close to read them lol.
D
Deleted member 11852
Guest
Just to be clear - I don't have a problem with the game's length. I've bought, played and enjoyed shorter games like Heavenly Sword and Modern Warfare 1, 2 and 3 where I only played the campaigns (many times, admittedly) and I've failed to complete a lot of games because I just tired of them before the game is over. I have too little free time to spend playing a game I'm not fully enjoying.
D
Deleted member 11852
Guest
I recall that Heavenly Sword seems very different to how reviews describe The Order. HS is not constantly cutting back and forth between gameplay and cutscenes, the combat is open and freeform and the game is most definitely not holding your hand through the game. I took the time to master Heavenly Sword's combat. The Heavenly Sword was my bitch 
I think there are only superficial similarities between the two games.
I think there are only superficial similarities between the two games.'
I hated DriveClub and I would probably hate this. But I think I agree with the "looks over substance"....
Billy Idol
Legend
Why do you even bring up Sony! No one mentioned it. Only for you, Sony is so important. Lol...you guys are funny
PS: I also think that reviewers had a personal vendetta against Ryse btw ;-)
Last edited:
Why do you even bring up Sony! No one mentioned it. Only for you, Sony is so important. Lol...you guys are funny
PS: I also think that reviewers had a personal vendetta against Ryse btw ;-)
A vendetta over what? Why would reviewers, in general, have some axe to grind with RAD? Every other game Ready At Dawn has made has been well received. It doesn't make sense.
Same with Ryse. The idea that the game was somehow ganged up on by reviewers who are out to get the developer is insane.
