Hrm. The size comparison between the 5700 and NV43 really seems impressive to me. For a chip that has twice the texel rate, and four times the z/pixel rate, the NV43 really isn't much bigger.991060 said:And don't forget to take a look at the comparsion on die size between MX4000, FX5700, NV43 and NV40:
http://www.d-cross.com/cgi-bin/TB_4/upload/28/nvidia-nv43-all-big.jpg
If the pictures are cut/paste next to each other, we can't be sure of the scale between them.Chalnoth said:Hrm. The size comparison between the 5700 and NV43 really seems impressive to me. For a chip that has twice the texel rate, and four times the z/pixel rate, the NV43 really isn't much bigger.991060 said:And don't forget to take a look at the comparsion on die size between MX4000, FX5700, NV43 and NV40:
http://www.d-cross.com/cgi-bin/TB_4/upload/28/nvidia-nv43-all-big.jpg
That is true, but your observation would seem to make things look even better for the NV43.RussSchultz said:If the pictures are cut/paste next to each other, we can't be sure of the scale between them.
On the 5700, for example, the passives (resistors and caps) seem smaller than the others.
You're right, it was just a brain fart on my part.Chalnoth said:Well, I had thought that the 5700 had half the z-rate of the 5900 per clock, putting it at 4 z ops per clock.
Chalnoth said:Hrm. The size comparison between the 5700 and NV43 really seems impressive to me. For a chip that has twice the texel rate, and four times the z/pixel rate, the NV43 really isn't much bigger.991060 said:And don't forget to take a look at the comparsion on die size between MX4000, FX5700, NV43 and NV40:
http://www.d-cross.com/cgi-bin/TB_4/upload/28/nvidia-nv43-all-big.jpg
DaveBaumann said:I'm not sure they outsourced the entire design, I think they brought in cell designs for some mathematical units, which were supposed to be more optimal in terms of layout.
Bear in mind, though, that they did remove some things (SIN/COS) and the two ALU's in each are not really duplicates of each other, and instructions are distributed between them.