Do I have a fiduciary responsibility to appease this board?
Obviously
Anyway, sorry to hear about your wife's injuries. However, my comment wasn't related to it being a 'core game' or not, but rather from the videos shown it looks very poor (to me) in itself.
And while I very much enjoy my Gears and Forza, I also partake in more casual pleasures, such as Singstar, Buzz and the like. Oft-times I will get these games out when people are around, along with the guitar games, etc. and also like the fact that they tend to be more palatable to my wife.
And because of this, I will likely pick up Kinect at some point. I'm warming to the idea of a controllerless experience to hopefully further bring my wife into my hobby, as well as for those times when a few people get invited around. There will be some casual games bought, no doubt. But I hope the ones I buy won't look as dire as Kinect Brain Training, as seen so far.
There's nothing wrong with the Brain Traning games per-se, but it seems to me the handheld platform is ideal for those activities. Have you played Sudoku in a newspaper? Can be fun. Have you played it on the DS? Still fun? Have you played it on a PC? Slightly less fun. And then, have you played it on the Xbox? Honestly, it's not fun at all.
I believe it's because pure puzzle games (and I'd put BT in that camp) are
intimate affairs. Kind of like reading a book. You wouldn't do that on a TV screen, because you need to be intimate with the book, to have it close to you, taking up all of your vision. Puzzle games are the same.
Of course, all of the above is 'imho', but that is also why I asked if you were serious. BT oin Kinect looks like a port of BT on the DS, and that's just poor. No allowance appears to have been made for the more expansive environment that it will be played in, no effort seems to have been made to make it more immersive or even interactive. Fitness Evolved has taken a simple concept, but made the very environment new, engaging and fresh.
Kinect BT looks like nothing more than a cheap cash-in on the BT brand.