seismologist said:
It really does . Something akin to this setup is most likely the future model of living room entertainment will be based on something more complete like a PC offers. Which is why it baffles me when I hear about all the hoops MS is jumping through just to get video to play on the television through your Xbox. Sony and MS have in mind a set top box idealogy. I'm kind of hoping Sony will stick to the Linux path to provide a more versatile solution.
Do you realize what a miniscule fraction of the population has the skills to set-up this sort of system?
You've said yourself you have never even used live, so why are you being so adament attacking something you haven't even used? It's ridiculous.
I don't know what hoops you think MS is jumping through, people have been easily streaming video and audio on modded XBOX's for years. If they don't allow for streaming video out of the box is simply to sell more Media Centre PC's.
Nobody wants a full OS on their console. No-one wants viruses and security upgrades. Wireless Keyboard and Mouse to a large screen tv is not the great solution you make it out to be, I have that set-up. It's ok but it's nowhere near my preferred method of playback?
You know what's much easier and more convenient? Fire up my xbox and use the controller to stream video and music off the PC. WAY better than using a mouse on my coffe table, or setting up some sort of desk in the living room.
Not only is it much easier to navigate and use, but the quality of videos is much better as it's streamed digitally and outputs through my XBOX component cables instead of a 20ft single-cable RCA out.
There's pretty much zero benefits of TV-out over console-streaming. I can't think of a single one, except maybe to play PC games with a mouse on your big screen. But what does that have to do with consoles?
These set-top boxes are the future not PC's with TV-out. The casual user 99.9% of people need a box that merges the content on their PC with the A/V equipment in their living room. That's what both these consoles will offer and it's excellent. Web Browsers, Linux and other PC-like features are completely excessive and while they might be "neat" they have no mass appeal.