Finished the game but I don't think I am going to do the platinum. Overall I really liked the game but I have being disappointed (my expectations were too high) and actually prefered the first game.
+ Technically the game is brilliant, even compared to others PS5 games. If only all others PS5 games ran and looked like this!
+ Graphics and framerate are basically perfect at 60fps and mostly native 4K.
+ Compared to the first game on PS5 I particularly liked the high resolution textures. Which I don't think has being highlighted enough on technical analysis I watched, for me the biggest improvement after the framerate is not the higher rendering resolution (compared to 4K CBR), it's the higher resolution assets, basically the game on PS5 has "4K" textures. It's also a big improvement compared to the first game running on Pro, here textures almost always look super sharp whatever the distance.
+ Combat has being refined and is better than the original
+ More interesting puzzles than the first game
+ More ennemy variation
+ World story still very interesting
+ Great side quests (often better than the main quest sadly)
+ Verticality is well done and feels fresh.
- Still not epic bosses like in the previous games. My favorite boss is still Baldur. Disappointing main bosses.
- Even more restricted by PS4 hardware (and HDD) than the first game. Here the number of loadings hidden in slow passages is awful. Sometimes once every 5mn, terrible stuff and kills the immersion. I really missed Demon's souls seamless experience here.
- Game feels very linear, more than the first game.
- Very disappointed by Kratos story. Kratos has not really a meaty story of his own here. The game is mainly about others characters stories.
- Game stories are very safe, like in a Marvel movie.
- Too much cinematic stuff (probably because of PS4 design though). Seems there is comparatively more cutscenes than in the first game.
- Quick Time Events (QTE) during bosses design is back baby! (Awful)
- Kratos is now soft and has become a typical Marvel hero (still safe design). So basically they killed the old Kratos and replaced him by someone else.
- Characters will spoil you the puzzle solution, often before you realize there is actually a puzzle to do. Usually I feel my intelligence has being insulted by the developers: "Why don't you look up?" etc. Please just shut up while I look at the beautiful graphics or loot stuff, don't spoil me the solution!