Formula 1 - The Eco Friendly Motorsport!

Denied? Hamilton admitted he pressed wrong button, that it was his fault, Dennis tried to claim it was technical problem, not Hamiltons fault.
 
Denied? Hamilton admitted he pressed wrong button, that it was his fault, Dennis tried to claim it was technical problem, not Hamiltons fault.

Ah yes .. I should've said 'a close family source'.

Compounding these rumours was a report in Montreal's newspaper La Presse, which quotes Hamilton directly as saying he indeed pushed the wrong button.

However, a source close to the Hamilton family has described the report as "absolute rubbish", telling autosport.com that Hamilton has not spoken to the Canadian newspaper or said anything as such to anyone.

http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/63613

US
 
It's irrelevant if he pressed the button or not.

The fact that it took more than 30 seconds for it to go back into gear suggests there was a fault.

I imagine they use the neutral button every pitstop and each one doesn't have the car stationary for 30 seconds before they can select a gear and drive off.
 
It's irrelevant if he pressed the button or not.

The fact that it took more than 30 seconds for it to go back into gear suggests there was a fault.

I imagine they use the neutral button every pitstop and each one doesn't have the car stationary for 30 seconds before they can select a gear and drive off.


having never seen an F1 steering wheel in person, he might have accidentally pressed it, and not noticed. He was pretty nervous already, it's not unfathomable.. wish they would play the radio traffic


hammie: "car has lost power, i think it's gearbox"

crew: "roger that.. *pause* try downshifting"

hammie: "negative, that doesn't work"

crew: "this is odd, we showing that you are in neutral ?"

hammie: "neutral ? aaah sh*t"


that could have took a good 20 seconds right there...
 
I think they would know instantly he put it in neutral to be honest with you.

They have numerous people looking at all the data throughout the race, something as obvious as him putting it in neutral would've been spotted instantly.
 
I think they would know instantly he put it in neutral to be honest with you.

They have numerous people looking at all the data throughout the race, something as obvious as him putting it in neutral would've been spotted instantly.

According to the interview, he had to "reboot" the gear control system, he pressed tons of buttons on the wheel apparently (say the reports) which could be this "rebooting the gear system", this could easily take that 20-30sec+?
 
According to the interview, he had to "reboot" the gear control system, he pressed tons of buttons on the wheel apparently (say the reports) which could be this "rebooting the gear system", this could easily take that 20-30sec+?
I think you misunderstand the main point I am trying to get out.

The neutral button would only put the car in neutral (needed for pitstops etc.) it would not take 30 seconds to get it back into gear if there wasn't some other fault.

They do not sit in the pitstop bashing buttons on the steering wheel getting ready for the go signal.

They stop, put it in neutral, put it in gear then go.
 
Not a fan of Formula 1 myself really, but I have one question:

Why are quote a few people in this thread apparently delighted at a report that Hamilton made an error rather than lost time due to a technical problem (an unsubstantiated report at that)?

Sheesh, I thought some fans of various graphic card vendors were bad enough! ;)
 
Not a fan of Formula 1 myself really, but I have one question:

Why are quote a few people in this thread apparently delighted at a report that Hamilton made an error rather than lost time due to a technical problem (an unsubstantiated report at that)?

Sheesh, I thought some fans of various graphic card vendors were bad enough! ;)

It's mostly due the fact how he has been described (mainly by UK press) as the best thing since sliced bread, how he has been so perfect etc and how he has himself actually been comparing already himself to some legends. So after all that, him making quite newbie-ish mistake, it's something many want to see, since it bings back to earth on many levels.
Same as how he clearly got too nervous in the couple last races, making really bad mistakes (driving too fast with his tyres to pits and thus crashing out to the sand in Japan, and then driving out couple times in Brazil)
 
It's mostly due the fact how he has been described (mainly by UK press) as the best thing since sliced bread, how he has been so perfect etc and how he has himself actually been comparing already himself to some legends.
Thats not really a British press thing. Take a look at the comments from competetive team managers.
 
http://www.grandprix.com/race/r784fripc.html

: (L'Equipe) Did you ever imagine that a rookie could be fighting for the world championship in the way that Lewis is?

Williams: Not to the level of competitiveness that Hamilton is doing. He is very special. Once every ten years they come along, like Ayrton and Michael. It is a very rare event and a fantastic event, and a story for Formula One.

Theissen: I am surprised too at how strong he is. I expected him to be able to win races in a strong car but to dominate the season in the way he did is quite exceptional. Although it is his first year in F1, I don't really see him as a rookie. In my view he is the best prepared driver who ever entered F1.

Todt: Normally a very talented driver in their first year in F1 doesn't drive for a winning team with a winning car. That was the opportunity he had and he used it very well. We can only have respect and admiration for what he has achieved this year.
 
Excluding Sir Frank, they're basicly saying he's good driver in a good team doing good, Williams is doing what you said, though.
 
Even though the question didn't phrase it in a manner that warrented it, Theissen is also using superlatives such as "dominating" and "exceptional" in his answer.
 
Not a fan of Formula 1 myself really, but I have one question:

Why are quote a few people in this thread apparently delighted at a report that Hamilton made an error rather than lost time due to a technical problem (an unsubstantiated report at that)?

Sheesh, I thought some fans of various graphic card vendors were bad enough! ;)

There's a lot of people in F1 who think that a rookie coming in and (nearly) winning the championship without doing his "F1 Apprenticeship" somehow belittles Formula 1. Personally, I think Max Mosely has the market cornered on that.
 
Even though the question didn't phrase it in a manner that warrented it, Theissen is also using superlatives such as "dominating" and "exceptional" in his answer.

Well I would guess that it would be pointing to how Hamilton has been in the point lead most of the season, which is quite exceptional and can be called "dominating" indeed, though as we saw, not enough
 
There's a lot of people in F1 who think that a rookie coming in and (nearly) winning the championship without doing his "F1 Apprenticeship" somehow belittles Formula 1.

I think Bernie Ecclestone said something similar in the build up to the Brazillian GP but he did mention afterwards that Lewis Hamilton had a long career ahead of him to win the championship anyway.
 
what do you mean "f1 Apprenticeship" he won the gp2 championship which is the feeder series
if you looking for someone who didnt do that there are other drivers to point the finger at cough*kimi* cough

but then again he does have a certain point :D
 
what do you mean "f1 Apprenticeship" he won the gp2 championship which is the feeder series
if you looking for someone who didnt do that there are other drivers to point the finger at cough*kimi* cough

but then again he does have a certain point :D

F1 drivers, even those that have come up from the feeder series are expected to do at least a year or two in one of the lesser teams or as a F1 test driver. The fact that Hamilton was given a F1 seat in a competitive car/team in his first year was a surprise. The fact that he's doing so well is an even bigger surprise. A lot of people didn't like that, as it made F1 success look easy.

There's been a lot of impressive feeder series drivers come into F1 and just not done well. Even with a decent car, the pressure gets to them.
 
Back
Top