I find the whole thing disingenuous. People claiming they watch streams and call the game play of some of the highest rated games mediocre.Saying they are not interested in God of War (95% MC) because of some character history shit? What we really have here is bias, plain and simple. You can't claim you like TPS like Gears and then say you don't like Uncharted and TLoU. They are the same genre and top rated games at that. If you run everything through a "I hate Sony" filter then you will find or exaggerate reasons not to buy or play them. "I don't like the story or the character". Sure....
How can someone say Dark Souls 1-3 are their favorite games and not mention Demon Souls or Bloodborne as top games to play? Oh ya, they are Sony games.
I'm calling bullshit, sorry if that is not PC.
So what you are saying is that anyone that likes Uncharted must like Gears of War, otherwise what they say is pure "bullshit" as you say?
And anyone that likes TLOU "must" like Gears of War?
Ummm, yeah, that's pure bullshit. All of those statements is as silly as when you said...
You can't claim you like TPS like Gears and then say you don't like Uncharted and TLoU.
While the gameplay in those are superficially similar, they aren't all THAT similar.
It's like saying that the original Doom and the original COD are both FPS games so anyone that likes one must by necessity like the other. And that's patently false as they are 2 completely different implementations of the FPS genre. While there's a great deal of overlap in people that like both, there's also a great deal of people that like one but dislike the other.
With the latest God of War, I'm finding the story interesting, but the gameplay uninteresting which is a complete 180 from the all the other God of War games. Granted, I've only gone through the first hour or so of the game (up to the first "god" fight, very cool), so my opinion could change, but there are so many things that just annoy me. The juggle mechanics are oddly disjointed. Hungry wolves that completely ignore the boy? Wolves by nature go after the weak, sickly, and young before going after prey that is more of a threat to them. The draug ignore the boy as well. At least the Troll fight had a pretense of the troll going after the boy which is much appreciated. I completely understand it's for gameplay reasons, but it's still annoying.
Gameplay is better than most open world games, but it still has a lot of open world tropes that pull me out of the game. For instance, Track this deer son! But, uh, hold on there's a chest here. Oh and I have to loot this burial casket here. Oh wait, there's a side path with stuff I don't want to miss. Again, I understand it's to support open world like gameplay. But then that's gameplay I don't find fun or attractive in the first place.
When will people understand that not everyone likes the same thing. The new GOW should end up being a huge success. There's a lot of good things in there (combat at higher difficulties is almost souls like, but without the weighty feel of a souls game) and while I found the story off putting at the start, it's growing on me. It's still not a game I would buy even if it was on a platform I own. That said, I expect this title to do significantly better than previous GOW games. TPS open world games (even though the first hour or so of GOW that I've played has been very linear) is the genre of choice right now if you want to sell a lot of games. Combine it with a good story and it's hard to fail.
Regards,
SB