The material shading looks dramatically better than the rather last-genish looking ones of the previous games, but yet still seem behind the curve compared to contemporary AAA games.
When it comes to gameplay though, I'm one that likes the feel of this new TR series, and if this is more of that I'm in.
The overly dark and serious tone is silly and out of place in my opinion, but part of me admires the devs for sticking to the vision they set out for this reboot since the first game instead of mutating it with each interation to apease the critics.