"Yes, but how many polygons?" An artist blog entry with interesting numbers

Cloofoofoo said:
That's interesting, so actual gameplay / physics animation don't slow down and sync just fine at 30 fps? Nice to see it's frame rate independent like that.

You might definitely be able to increase detail considerably then if you keep it consistent 30 fps. ( Might be able to use one of those Xbox 1 doa stages even) I wonder if one can change something in the 1st read to force 30 fps frame lock.
Click to expand...
No, It depends, when It is GPU bound It runs at 30 fps at 1x speed when It IS CPU bound It slows downs, or so It seems, but I found a memory address that locks the Game to 30fps.
 
Not really as you can see it's chugging in a lot of places and next to no collision on anything which frees the CPU up.

Pushing it farther than it can realistically go.
 
Last edited:
davis.anthony said:
Not really as you can it's chugging in a lot of places and next to no collision on anything which frees the CPU up.

Pushing it farther than it can realistically go.
Click to expand...

And collision i still there as well as phsyics( ik bones , gravity) nothing is freed up and these stages are higher in vertex counts than the default one. What youre looking at is mismatch between the visual model and the physics/collision model because he has swapped the visual one but not collision one yet( not sure if he has the tools to swap the collision models). not to mention he added material to stages( specular is heavy dc cpu) like in the desert stage the statues have specular if u look carefully. Theres MORE going on than on the defaut stage.

it shows you dont know how it actually works.
 
The stutter is from my capture card, I say it in the description.... That's why I usually capture off screen and I am reluctant to use my cheap capture card when I want to show how it runs on real hardware...

There is only one instance when it really does chugs for a split second. ( Soul Calibur 2 chugs on PS2 and I see no one doubting about its power...)

Also the game always has 2 stages loaded in ram, if tecmo improved the engine and made it load just one stage things could go beyond what they did. What at this point that is just fantasy, there is also a hard limit in the engine of the size of the fes for stages because between fights and custscenes it loads I. The background that's why the realtime intro switches between different stages and characters seemingly without loading times, except in the spiral stage.
If you mess with the ram in real-time you can switch between stages without loading but only from the current to the previous.
 
Last edited:
davis.anthony said:
Unfortunately certain people still like to live in fantasy land and dream that DC was this super powerful machine that never reached it's full potential because PS2 killed it off.
Click to expand...

BY 1998 standards it was super powerful though, that's simply how it is. The only thing more powerful were the Model 3 boards which were thousands of dollars each and even then the DC had some advantages. It was a lot faster than my Pentium 2 400 and Voodoo 2 - at least in terms of graphics (the Pentium 2 would have been faster at some simulation and scripting stuff no doubt).

It's just that technology was moving at a breakneck pace and two years was a long time then.

Arguably no machine ever truly reaches it's full potential, but having such a short life and limited development support meant there was little to no time to experiment with more advanced techniques that the system allowed, and assets were being made with primitive tools by developers who were still learning how to make best use of all the extra capability they'd gotten over PS1. The amazing Shenmue 1/2 for example was a Saturn remake made without automated version control, and bug management was done manually using an excel spreadsheet. Most of the assets for Shenmue 1 and 2 were actually made before the DC launched in Japan, and the only use of bump mapping was a seemingly experimental hand made application on a coin you looked at in a menu.

(Side note, but there's a great Shenmue Yu Suzuki talk with Mark Cerny translating, the game being as mindblowing as it was at the time is due to an insane vision, talent and raw determination. Mark Cerny being friends with Yu Suzuki is the icing on the cake).

If PS2 had seen only limited support and died off around the end of 2002 it wouldn't be the legendary system it turned out to be. PS1 software came on loads over the years, as did PS2 software. Somehow slap bang in the middle of these Dreamcast software wouldn't? This isn't a DC vs PS2 thing, it's a development thing.
 
function said:
BY 1998 standards it was super powerful though, that's simply how it is. The only thing more powerful were the Model 3 boards which were thousands of dollars each and even then the DC had some advantages. It was a lot faster than my Pentium 2 400 and Voodoo 2 - at least in terms of graphics (the Pentium 2 would have been faster at some simulation and scripting stuff no doubt).

It's just that technology was moving at a breakneck pace and two years was a long time then.

Arguably no machine ever truly reaches it's full potential, but having such a short life and limited development support meant there was little to no time to experiment with more advanced techniques that the system allowed, and assets were being made with primitive tools by developers who were still learning how to make best use of all the extra capability they'd gotten over PS1. The amazing Shenmue 1/2 for example was a Saturn remake made without automated version control, and bug management was done manually using an excel spreadsheet. Most of the assets for Shenmue 1 and 2 were actually made before the DC launched in Japan, and the only use of bump mapping was a seemingly experimental hand made application on a coin you looked at in a menu.

(Side note, but there's a great Shenmue Yu Suzuki talk with Mark Cerny translating, the game being as mindblowing as it was at the time is due to an insane vision, talent and raw determination. Mark Cerny being friends with Yu Suzuki is the icing on the cake).

If PS2 had seen only limited support and died off around the end of 2002 it wouldn't be the legendary system it turned out to be. PS1 software came on loads over the years, as did PS2 software. Somehow slap bang in the middle of these Dreamcast software wouldn't? This isn't a DC vs PS2 thing, it's a development thing.
Click to expand...
Where can I find the talk?
Shenmue 1 I m convinced was very rushed and even has graphical implementations more akin to how the Sega Saturn worked. Shenmue 2 greatly improved but I am sure it was also rushed and if devs gave it more time it might have surprised us.

The games it got up until it's death werent exploring much its capabilities.
 
Nesh said:
Where can I find the talk?
Shenmue 1 I m convinced was very rushed and even has graphical implementations more akin to how the Sega Saturn worked. Shenmue 2 greatly improved but I am sure it was also rushed and if devs gave it more time it might have surprised us.

The games it got up until it's death werent exploring much its capabilities.
Click to expand...
 
Sonicfan said:

Jesus! The shenmue Face demos have absolutely nothing on this!!! How did you get the lips and eyes to look so natural!!!??? @EsppiraK
Click to expand...
That's because that's how the model was generated in metahuman before it was imported. After that its a matter of basic normal smoothing and textures. I m not sure if it was decimated before import to reduce polygons

Back then 3D artists had to manually model characters, without having the advanced sculpting tools we have today like Zbrush nor advanced software that generate models like Metahuman or Character Creator with proper anatomy and realism. They had to do that manually while having in mind a polygon budget that made sure it would run smoothly and be easy to animate. Plus they had to add the textures either through manual painting or manipulation of real photos (like Max Payne) that kind of matched the model's geometry.

Such model like this one was an impossible or nonsensical task for 3D game artists of the time and it would have required tremendous work to create and then animate like Irimajiri's head in that infamous tech demo.

The question is how many polygons is this model made of? It tanks the framerate
 
Karamazov said:
shenmue at the time of release made a huge impact graphically, too bad you're looking at it with today's eyes(but logical), at the time it was mindblowing.
Click to expand...
I was also impressed when it was released. But retrospective observation can also reveal what we couldn't see back then. The DC's premature death, improvements made in Shenmue 2, comparisons with other games of that generation, knowing more about Shenmue's development and observing these graphical experiments are pretty telling about where the DC might have headed and what Shenmue could have been under different circumstances
 
Nesh said:
That's because that's how the model was generated in metahuman before it was imported. After that its a matter of basic normal smoothing and textures. I m not sure if it was decimated before import to reduce polygons

Back then 3D artists had to manually model characters, without having the advanced sculpting tools we have today like Zbrush nor advanced software that generate models like Metahuman or Character Creator with proper anatomy and realism. They had to do that manually while having in mind a polygon budget that made sure it would run smoothly and be easy to animate. Plus they had to add the textures either through manual painting or manipulation of real photos (like Max Payne) that kind of matched the model's geometry.

Such model like this one was an impossible or nonsensical task for 3D game artists of the time and it would have required tremendous work to create and then animate like Irimajiri's head in that infamous tech demo.

The question is how many polygons is this model made of? It tanks the framerate
Click to expand...
40K according to @EsppiraK on NeoGaf
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

A
Full transcript of John Carmack's QuakeCon 2005 Keynote
3 4 5
Replies
98
Views
32K
nemisis
N
Back
Top