Hmm, very interesting.
I kind of agree GOW is an ugly game, despite incredible technical merits. That's one of my problems with it. (but then again if you say that, you'd have to throw Resistance in to that boat as well).
It can be pretty at times though. I remember playing co-op with my brother (pretty much his first time with a next gen console, though he plays WOW), showing off the graphics by examining an towering iron statue in a courtyard. It was pretty nice. That is what the UE3.0 does so well at, statues, because they use that normal mapping to get the detail in many million polygon models down to game level. But in GOW, the colors or lack thereof can get oppressive, so one of the things that made that particular statue "pretty" was that it was in one of the more colorful outdoor enviroments that are a relief to the eyes in Gears.
BUT, I think the Halo 3 shots could be said to look pretty by that comparison. They have clean lines and you cant really say Halo features a destroyed world (well, in the outdoor areas).
Another example of this is Mass Effect. I think part of what makes that game so appealing to me is that it's "style" is so different. Odd, clean, whatever. I wouldn't call it happy, but it's clean with distinct colors. I think that bothered me the most about Gears, it's like everything is run through a decolorizing filter. There are no "brash" colors.
Yeah, Lost Planet is another one..that is going to feature "clean" visuals. And the walking animations and your whole character are just cool.
I'm down on UT series a lot too though. It's not what it used to be. Game designers need to focus more on "awesome" if you ask me. The original UT, this is a perfect example, the famous facing worlds map. Besides being graphically impressive for it's day, that map just showed a sense of wonder and creativity to it's setting that you dont see in the new, inferior UT games.
For example, if I'm lead designer on UT2k7, I'd probably make some kind of "No run down factories" type of rule. Because you know that is what 80% of the levels in UT2k7 are going to be.
Ugh, I'm really down on Epic as well. Gears was a real let down imo. It all comes down to creativity and they seem to lack it lately.
All that said, I'm still REALLY looking forward to UT2k7, probably, maybe my #1 most anticipated game, and especially how well each next gen console handles it's graphics...
________
NEXIUM INJURY LAWYER