The lawsuit was about a specific implementation of rumble, and I think certain patterns of rumble. Only a selection of DualShock games infringed the patent. Sony could release a DS controller with a different rumble tech without problem (unless they don't do their homework and infringe someone else's patents!). The actuall design and layout of DS isn't a problem and it wasn't for any legal reasons Sony designed the Batarang.jvd said:when i said i wonder what they are doing , i meant in regards to the controler . They lost that innovation lawsuit and are not allowed by law to make the dual shock anymore . So i'm expecting the new controler will be based on something else . HOpefully its better tha nwhat they showed at e3 .