But even the story is being criticised as not ending, which is the reward of a good story. It should be a stand-alone story that completes, with an optional extension to a sequel if the game is well received. As it is, the sequel may never happen and story never get resolved if sales are poor, leaving owners of 1886 with a very pretty unfinished story. Sales are bound to be low because second hand is going to be extremely available - short play time and no replayability, buy, play, sell. One disc could change hands a dozen times a month.