Given GTA's history, why does your interest lie with GTA4's graphical prowness? If the was an award for "Best Ugliest game that Rocks", the GTA franchise would win every time.
Hmm either my memory is absolutely top notch or it plays game(lol) with me. When i saw GTA3 the first time it was on a demo stand, i thought it looked pretty nice if a bit bland and not something that i would consider state of the art.
The violence and mayheim on the screen got me interested, when i then understood the incredible scope of the game and the (for me) never before seen freedom in a giant 3D world i was impressed. I thought i was looking at the future (i guess i was).
GTA:SA for all it´s shortcommings had the scope and size as an excuse and i don´t recall any game having the same scope and looking anywhere as good.
When played GTA4 may do the same as GTA3 did, look amazing for a game it´s size
I wish they would have selected something else than a Russian Thug to be the main character, i don´t get it