personally, I loved and still love Crysis 1's visuals. They went all over the place with Crysis 2 and especially 3. for me, Crysis 3 didn't know what it wanted to be visually. But, yes, in such matters, it comes down to tastes, opinions, etc, but going from the first level to around the mid and then the end, the game didn't really potray the story with its visuals. It started with a very high note on the rain drenched ship, the crytek fan in me jumped up and down, but after that as the game progressed they forgot that their fab visuals can also help carry the mood for each level.
But they did wow me to heaven even on the ps3, especially in the last level.
Like in life, I guess, we can't have everything in one product. But we sure hope we could. We can look forward to The Order 1886 for some great atmosphere(but they wouldn't have Cryengine), I guess and hope Naughty Dog makes another Last of Us perfection. A Stalker SOC doesn't happen everyday either.