scooby_dooby said:
If you take an honest look at the planned titles on 360 over the first year of launch, it is an extremely diverse line-up of games. Anyone who says otherwise really isn't giving them a fair shake.
I'm giving them a very fair shake, and the fact of the matter is their lineup is once again overly stacked in favor of FPS, racing and sports games, and PC ports. 'Extremely diverse' is the last thing I would call their launch (and beyond) lineup.
scooby_dooby said:
In short, they are launching first, with extremely good games and very deep advertising pockets. When PS3 does eventuall launch it will be competing with ~100 360 games, and many 2nd generation games already being released, very many exlusives as well.
There are so many things I disagree with in this paragraph. First off, 'extremely good games'? Neither of us can make any sort of assumption on whether or not this will indeed be true, but based on the E3 showing, I have far more doubts than hopes. And really, try and name a single game, let alone an exclusive, other than Gears of War that is releasing a good bit after launch (but prior to the PS3 launch) that has the potential to be a big hit? 360's lineup so far is very, very weak, but that is expected; the system is just starting out.
PS3 launching against ~100 360 games? Like hell that'll happen. I'll be surprised if MS gets 20-30 games out this holiday, and while I'm skeptical PS3 will hit in the Spring, it won't launch a full year later. 70+ more games in 6-8 months, half of which is the traditionally slow time of year? Not gonna happen. 2nd gen games won't be hitting yet either, and I will bet you cold hard cash that 75% or more of the 360 titles released will hit the PS3 within its first 3 months.
scooby_dooby said:
The key in my mind, is the fact that for the first time ever, PS will not have the most games, situations will be reversed, and this will cause the shift in the US market.
This is simply a prediction of yours, and I'm willing to bet it will not come true. I expect the PS3 to once again have at least 20-30% more titles than the 360, if not more.