When news of the Wii controller first appeared, I was really excited about the prospect of this "more real" way of gameplay and was one of the ones defending it against the skeptics. But after seeing it in use, I have second thoughts about it. As someone who isn't a big fan of the dance dance games and other games which require a lot of movement, I'm now seeing that this is what the Wii, and to some extent, the PS3 controller are really just an extension of this. I watched many demonstrations from E3 and Nintendo's promotional material and was really turned off by it. After thinking about why that was the case, I've come to the realization that what I want in a game is a lot of control without a lot of movement. The Wii and other motion controllers are doing the opposite. The virtual tennis and virtual fishing just didn't look like something I want to do. I was emabarassed to see the people looking like fools playing it. What are they doing? And the guy doing the PS3 motion demonstration looked like those people who lean during driving games. In one of the (yes I know, exaggerated) commercials, a player who was playing Metroid dived off the couch to simulate a similar move in the game. Errrr, no. Not doing that (Yes, I realize it was just done for dramatic effect). Either way, I'm not excited about doing charades in my own living room to play a game. Perhaps if I actually sit down to play it, I might change my mind, but at this point, I've reversed course about my excitment. I know everyone will feel different about this since people have different comfort levels in regard to controllers, and I don't want to single out the Wii because it seems like the whole industry is moving this way. So how about it? How do others feel about this "more real, more movement" type of gameplay that we may all have to get used to?