I'm confused, do you or do you not want Sony to do 'more'?
Not so much more, just widen the range of titles. It's no more effort and no more cost from what I can see.
Believe it or not Sony did listen to what was being said. They could have done a MS a given everyone specific titles, but instead they've given people a choice...OK the selection might not be to everones choice but that's the way it goes. I'd much rather have a better selection...
So you don't actual disagree with what others want, except in your case as you benefit from the titles on offer, it's no great loss to you. If you possessed all five titles, would you be a little more interested in a wider range of titles, perhaps explaining your situation to Sony so they might change their plans to accommodate persons like yourself?
Sure I can see why someone might say "well I never bought the game before so why would I want it now?" - well often the reason they never bought it before was either you suspected you might not like it, or you were not prepared to pay for it.
I've said as much myself. Could be I didn't buy Infamous because I couldn't afford it, or there were other titles that I preferred, and this opportunity is a good one. But then it could be I didn't buy it because I tried the demo and didn't find any enjoyment. In the latter case, offering a few more titles means catering for a wider audience.
I just find it hard to believe someone cannot find some value in this offer - hell - you don't even know what will be in the PS+ pack yet...
I've said as much myself! PS+ may offer good discounts on content a person wants, and so be a good gain over the month. At this point we aren't sure though, and PS+ hasn't offered me much opportunities that I would have benefited from. There will be other people in the same boat where the promise of PS+ membership doesn't sound worth much to them. All we know at this point for certain is that there's a choice of five games, not to everyone's liking. If Sony were to extend the selection, they'd please more people. If that's something they want to do, please people, then they still have time to change their selection.
You seem to agree this would be a good idea, so I don't understand where your complaints against the disgruntled minority comes from!