Who wants to rent Uncharted to play for 4 hours and not even come close to finishing it?
It's an option for sharing game experiences round people's houses. Sitting down and watching/hot-seating playing a game can be plenty of fun. I showed the latest MGS:TPP gameplay to my friends and they were interested in doing just that like we did with other MGS games. I can definitely see playing Uncharted or similar game as an evening's entertainment. If not those games, other games like LBP or some karting game with immediate, short, pick-up-and-play value.
Obviously a gamer wanting to play through a 20 hour game isn't going to do it in 4h chunks, but there are other very economical options for them. 7 days for $8 is plenty for a fair number of AAA story driven games, and that's damned good value IMO. Perhaps too good if the service is excellent as it undervalues full releases. If I could rent PS4 games for the same price, buying them would be way more expensive and something I could end up avoiding (hypothetically).
The idea of a subscription service is nice, but looking at those prices I'd be shocked if it cost less than $15 a month. That puts you at $180 a year. If the subscription is any cheaper than that, there's have to be some pretty strict limitations on use.
That's probably true.
At that price, fuck it. You can buy a bunch of new games for that price, especially if you factor in indie titles.
But you're unlikely to be buying new AAA games at that price. $180 a year is the price of three AAA games. The subscription then isn't that expensive, as long as you get your money's worth. Edit: Sorry, you meant old new games, like Uncharted 3 still shrink-wrapped or platinum editions. Yeah, eBay and the second hand market does put price pressure on a service like this, but there's still a convenience value to this service. It's basically the same with movie rentals. You can pick up second hand DVDs for cheaper than rentals, but people still rent.
There isn't a clear price advantage over getting a PS3 to play old games, and it's a lesser experience.
The quality is worse, but I disagree on the price advantage thing. If you own a PS4 and no PS3 and want to play Uncharteds 1, 2, and 3 before 4 comes out, you'd have to spend $100 on 2nd hand PS3 (eBay average is quite a bit higher) and another $20 on the three games, or $24 for three weeks, one week each, or $45 for three months and take your time.
It all depends on usage, but overall I don't think the prices are unreasonable. Sony don't want it to be such amazing value that they undermine their core business, and there are expensive running costs to factor in. If Sony's plan is to move gaming to the cloud via this service, perhaps it costs too much, but if their plan is to offer BC to the niche that wants to revisit a few games, I think it's reasonable value. Each price-point has its justification for type of game/experience you're after, and the price at that point doesn't seem excessive.