expletive said:
Common sense aside, just seems partially implausible that they could sell half the total # of Xbox1's sold in 12 months doesnt it?
Different market situations, different sales constraints and momentum? Your analogy above is not perfect because while MS is now facing 2 new competitors, last time Sony had a head start and the 360 co-launched with the GCN. Sony had an edge in software and even price and the GCN came in lower priced. MS also did not have a lot of game support. This time around they have a game library head start, a lower price than Sony, and Wii is not competing necessarily for the same consumers. Last time the Xbox did not have online, while this time Live co-launched. Production issues are also different, with the 360 having far more production shortages + higher demand than the Xbox1 had. Even if Sony does hit their 6M target, they are going to generate a huge stir and shortages which may also steer people to the 360/Wii.
As for games, the 360 has more than just Gears of War, Splinter Cell, and Madden in 2006. For big titles you have Forza 2, Mass Effect, Lost Planet, and Viva Pinata. Those titles are surrounded by a pretty solid supporting cast as well. Now and through Summer there is Prey, Chromehounds, MotoGP, Table Tennis, Battle for Middle Earth 2, Saint's Row, Test Drive, among others. This fall should see FEAR, Crackdown, maybe Too Human on top of the 3rd party titles like Rainbox Six: Vegas and so forth. Of course you need to consider the sales impact of "coming soon" titles like Bioshock, Alan Wake, Halo 3, Fable 2 and 3rd party software like Medal of Honor, Brother in Arms, the Darkness. Sure someone may pick up a 360 for Gears in anticipation of Brother in Arms in the Winter and Halo 3 in the Spring. And we cannot discount the back library which is currently keeping sales pretty brisk.
For people who have wanted a 360, but could not get one due to shortages, it is not just Gears of War or Splinter Cell that will motivate a sale in any given month, but also having some really good next gen games on the market as well. Oblivion, GRAW, CoD2, and PGR3 have all sold well and been critically acclaimed. I have not chosen/bought a next gen system yet, but out of all the games I have seen coming this year and already out, PGR3 is still at the very top of my "wish" list. If I could get it on the PC I would in a heartbeat.
360 sales are more complex than comparing Xbox1 sales and what games will be available what month. For all we know MS may hit a "wall" with the enthusiest market at some point and we may discover that casual gamers are not impressed with the lineup and price. Or we may continue to see brisk sales that totally tap the supply well into 2007.
I think MS's numbers are pretty aggressive. Summer is typically pretty slow, and they have 2 months to sell 2M consoles. Demand is high, but that is a lot of units and will be relying on momentum, future game previews, and the current library to push that. I am not sure anyone knows how many units MS would sell if they totally saturated the market right now, but 2M sounds like a lot for such a slow time of year. I guess they are banking on people to have kept an interest.