The dock does make good sense in my mind, but it doesn't make sense not to *also* have a HDMI port on the device. Oh well, I really should stop expecting too much from MS. I bet this is the same kind of retarded reasoning that led to the Palm Pre not having microSDHC (zomg it'll ruin the exterior!)
Also, they are in the weird position where they are both cheaper and more expensive in different ways than an iPod Touch. This is not an ideal competitive positioning. They really should have made two SKUs like Apple will. Oh well, live and learn - at least it should be a very solid foundation unlike the original Zune. And the two biggest selling points IMO (battery life & gaming) haven't even been unveiled yet... I might be tempted to buy one if it's cheap enough, although I love the iPhone/iPod Touch apps too much to consider it as a potential replacement.
Also, they are in the weird position where they are both cheaper and more expensive in different ways than an iPod Touch. This is not an ideal competitive positioning. They really should have made two SKUs like Apple will. Oh well, live and learn - at least it should be a very solid foundation unlike the original Zune. And the two biggest selling points IMO (battery life & gaming) haven't even been unveiled yet... I might be tempted to buy one if it's cheap enough, although I love the iPhone/iPod Touch apps too much to consider it as a potential replacement.