Analysis of SONY/MS/N press conferences by gamespy....they are so pro-MS.....here is an example...
Link
Why Nintendo, Why?!?
Raymond "Psylancer" Padilla
This year's press conferences were a bit underwhelming. I thought it would be similar to last year -- Microsoft would take the most risks, Sony would be the steadiest, and Nintendo would have the best games. I thought Microsoft put on the best show in 2002 and I was expecting Nintendo to go balls out -- out of necessity -- in 2003.
This year Microsoft was the winner by default. It had an above-average presentation, but compared to Sony's mostly lackluster performance and Nintendo's paltry outing Microsoft clearly had the best pre-E3 presser.
Microsoft is becoming the console for action gamers.
Doom 3 was so beautiful that I had a hard time believing that it was running on an Xbox. The company closed out the show with a fabulous showing of Halo 2. Though the game has been delayed to next year, what was shown was so sweet that it's worth the wait. I was also really fascinated by Microsoft Music Mixer, an application that allows Xbox owners to view digital photos, organize music files, create photo shows set to music, and, most importantly, perform karaoke. Most gamers will scoff at Music Mixer, but it makes the Xbox more appealing to mainstream consumers. Think about it. If an unknowledgeable buyer looks at Xbox, PlayStation 2, and GameCube, he or she sees a bunch of boxes that play games. If one of those boxes lets you sing karaoke and view photos, that's the one they're going to buy.
Being the market leader by a longshot, Sony played everything slow and steady. It's way ahead of the competition and it doesn't need to take big risks; this was reflected in its press conference.
Gran Turismo 4, Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater, and the next Grand Theft Auto are great feathers to have in your cap, but those games are hardly surprises. Sony's announcement that EA Sports games will be online with PlayStation 2 only was also quite a coup. Despite all this news, the crowd response was fairly contained until Sony unveiled PlayStation Pocket (PSP). Though it's pretty much vaporware at this point, the fact that Sony is getting into the handheld space is terribly exciting. Though its presentation was a little flat, Sony definitely went out with bang, thanks to PSP.
Last, and definitely least was Nintendo. This press conference is usually the fanboy's choice, partially because Nintendo has the most history and partially due to all the Nintendo fan sites (who scream and clap way more than anyone should at a press conference). But even the most ardent fanboy couldn't back this pony. Man, oh man what a weak showing. As cool as Mario Kart is, it should not be the biggest game at your press conference. It was just a sad presser, complete with unexciting games, no online strategy to speak of, and an overemphasis on connectivity. It's especially troublesome since as a game fan, almost every journalist is pulling for Nintendo to put on a good show. Instead it was Weak Sauce City.
Three men enter, one man wins.
Bryn "hardcore_pawn" Williams
I've been attending E3 console press conferences for the last six years. I'm not happy too report that this year was the first year when I felt slightly disappointed with the 2003 line-up of games from Nintendo. But I'll get to that in a minute. It's my opinion that out of the three major playaz -- Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo -- the clear winner of the press conference three-way battle was Microsoft. The games shown at the Xbox presser were far more stunning than those shown at Sony or Nintendo. DOOM 3 and Halo 2 completely blew me away and nothing else came close.
It's fair to say that Microsoft's event lacked the personality of the Nintendo press conference -- i.e. there were no comedic appearances by revered and slightly weird Japanese developers -- as well as lacking the big stars of the Sony event (Tiger Woods and Cedric the Entertainer were funny) but that really didn’t matter in the long run. When the Xbox footage of DOOM 3 was shown on two huge crystal clear screens, the crowd went bananas. With a sweet live demo of Bungie's Halo 2 showing off some of the best-looking FPS action I can remember seeing, it was gonna be hard for the other guys to beat.
Sony's event kicked off with the usual barrage of statistics, facts and figures stating that the PlayStation 2 is still the king of the consoles, but after that less-than interesting stage had passed, we were treated to a nice long look at the incredibly sweet Gran Turismo 4 in development by Polyphony. EA kicked things up a notch with a whirlwind demo of all its major PS2 online-exclusive sports titles -- enter Tiger and Cedric -- and with some further announcements stating that Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto series and Konami's Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater would premier exclusively on the PS2, it was a good time to be a PS2 owner. With a new PS2 hardware bundle coming soon -- including the broadband adaptor for $199 total -- and the sneaky last minute announcement of Sony's PSP handheld system (hitting fall 2004) Sony went out on a high note.
Now to Nintendo. Oh, Nintendo. Let's first understand that there are some really sweet games for both GameCube and Game Boy Advance coming out this year. These include Mario Kart: Double Dash!! game, F-Zero GX, Pikmin 2, FF Tactics Advance, Geist and many more. I just couldn't help but feel that after Nintendo essentially stole the whole E3 show last year, this year's line-up isn't as strong. I love what its doing with the whole GCN/GBA connectivity thing, but I was really waiting for a new Zelda or Mario announcement, or something else huge and unique from Miyamoto. I'm still excited about all three companies -- but the clear winner of the press conference wars was Microsoft. Here's hoping that the DOOM III footage really was running on the Xbox!
..........
so for them MGS3/GT4/GTAnext are nothing new so Sony lost and D3 and H2 were brand new concepts so MS won...huh!