Personal preference. I really just cringe at "Chicago" style pizza. I prefer my pizzas flat, crispy and with more toppings, rather than more crust and cheese, which are what Chicago pizzas are all about.
Yes, it's often the case that those who lie within the population that is inherently inferior feel a sense of resentment and hostility towards the superior
. Nietszche points out rather beautifully how questions of weak vs. strong get transmuted into matters of good vs. evil.
Seriously, though, a proper Chicago style pizza should have more sauce and toppings than any other variety of pizza in addition to more cheese and crust (there are variations like simply thicker crusts, but those are counter-transitional forms more so than Chicago-style pizza per se). Formally speaking, Chicago-style is a magnification of all things pizza, even if that magnification turns a few things on its head. When I see New York style pizza, I see something that was intended to be a snack, and not really a meal. It's the metaphorical fast-food pizza you walk around with and munch on as opposed to a sit-down-and-eat-at-the-table pizza. No one in Chicago claims that they're doing something more authentic or "properly" -- just that after all the transformations that have happened to pizza throughout the US, it took Chicago to finally get it right.
All said, though, I don't cringe at New York style. It's a nice light snack once in a while. What does make me cringe quite often is California-style pizza. It just smacks of trying to be unique for the sake of being unique rather than purposefully so. And every California-style pizza I've ever had, even the ones that aren't necessarily weird, has an utterly tasteless and dry crust coupled everything that goes on it is in such light quantities (although there are occasionally a few I've had that have proportionally overdone it on the cheese and garlic).
About the only chain pizza I've gotten to like a little lately is Round Table, and I've never seen them outside of California. Still, they cover the gamut of what chains are expected to cover including the California-style oddities that are expected in the state, and their pan pizza is pretty much what I'd expect Pizza Hut's to be like if it had actual cheese and wasn't stewed in a vat of grease. Still, for all that, homemade trounces everything, with true Chicago-style being a close second.