Uncharted versus Gears of War 2 comparison

[Moon Light Knight]

I saw this on the GS forums and I thought this might be interesting to everyone.

Part 1
http://kineticninja.blogspot.com/2009/01/naughty-dog-realtime-graphics-and.html

Part 2
http://kineticninja.blogspot.com/2009/01/naughty-dog-realtime-graphics-and_31.html

 

[Mobius1aic]

Difficult comparison considering they are both entirely different looking games, though I must say that Uncharted is more visually appealing to me as I like the tropical locations. Also one must note that both games suffer from texture fade in too.

 

[Shifty Geezer]

I'm closing this thread. The comparison doesn't make much sense. If there was perhaps a focus on the artisitic differences, or specific technical differences, perhaps there'd be a point to it. Otherwise one may as well post a comparison of Pixel Junk Monsters versus Grid Wars.

The blogger needs to be sure that in a comparison, the points being compared are highlighted and conclusions made. 'Game x demonstrates yadayada versus game y as evidenced in these captures' sort of thing. But as we're comparing lemons to grapefruit in this case, it makes very little sense on the whole unless you want to consider one specific common feature like vitamin C content...