Wow, 1UP were raving about this on 1UP-Yours this week. Basically, what really made it sink in was they mentioned the 8.5 they gave R+C, and how they copped a lot of feedback for it. Then Shane (who is known for being a little Sony-sided on occasion) said something along the lines of "well, when you play SMG, you really will understand exactly why this game deserved a much higher score - and this really is a much better game." It also makes you smile at sites getting criticised for trying to use the full range of scores, rather than keeping 95% of games between 80 and 100.
Now I'm reconsidering my Wii purchase... if only these games looked better on HD LCD's. Hopefully I can convince some Wii-owning friends to buy and let me borrow.