a) Games are not "bigger than ever." Well, not unless we're talking about Wii, they're not...but you certainly can't attribute Wii's success to steroid-charged space marines mangling zombie aliens in a dystopian wasteland.
b) Comic book fantasies aren't any closer to reality than cartoon characters.
c) This thread is about what we personally would like; sales are irrelevant.
On that note, I wish developers would learn when not to use an effect. I'm playing Dead Space on PS3, and overall, it looks fantastic...except for the self-shadowing, which is glitchy and twitchy. They should have left the effect out IMO, because it's just distracting and doesn't look good at all.
Their self-shadowing implementation is not perfect and could be better but the game would look worse and inconsistent without self-shadowing.