The good, the bad and the ugly.

Guden Oden

Senior Member
Legend
This move is surely one of the best I've ever seen, and I often put on the DVD just to have something on in the background, and then I watch the unforgettable moments for a while, and then go back listening whilst surfing the web or posting... If you can appreciate the slow and methodical way the plot moves along, I'm sure you'll agree how great this piece of movie history really is. Certainly is the best damn western movie I ever saw, though I agree I haven't watched a very large percentage of the total. Most of them must be completely forgettable however, that I am sure of! :p

This movie is so amazing, so epic in scope. It has everything, sharp storyline despite its simplicity, incredible sets and environments, a classic set of protagonists and antagonists, awesome dialog - though sparse as it is - and a mesmerizing music score.

This isn't a western though... Not really. It's more like a faery tale, or a legend. The place it is acted out isn't texas either. It's actually purgatory. None of the people seen on screen are alive, they're all dead, atoning for their misdeeds until they have redeemed themselves. As we see with the drunkard of a union captain who dies at the end by the way, he finished paying off his sins by setting Tuco and Blondie on the task of blowing up that bridge, and was rewarded for it.

Well, actually, speaking of Blondie. I'm not totally sure he is a sinner after all. He seems more like he's on his way passing through hell, rather than living it. He did have that unfortunate experience in the desert, but sure enough, that horse-carriage came along and saved his hide. He might be a puppet, stringed along by someone else, but I don't think so. More like he's got protection, someone higher looking out for him, though he's probably unaware of it himself.

Everybody just toils away around him, living life such as it is after death in that dry, dusty landscape, and then dying all over again. Again and again...
 
This movie is great, even better when watched in the context of the trilogy. TBH though if you haven't seen it you need to watch Once Upon A Time In The West. As a stand-alone movie it is superb, and the first 20 minutes are arguably the best opening sequence in the history of cinema (on a par with the opening sequence to Laurence of Arabia IMO).
 
This past spring has seen my first venture into the world of "spaghetti westerns" aswell (ended up buying fistful, few dollars more, good-bad-ugly and once upon a time in the west on DVD, of course)..
I like your interpretation of it, and although good-bad-ugly is only my second favourite of the four, behind Once upon a time, it is also among the best five movies I've ever seen.
The music, the images, the actors and the story all combine to make a fantastic journey through, as you say, purgatory.. I really don't see why current directors like Tarantino don't go further in their attempts to pay homage to Leone/Morricone and their kind.. :)

It's really close to an artform - but in a good way!

Kind regards
Kjetil
 
Let's not forget the dying confederate lieutnant who got his last smoke.... the music score is superb.

;^)
 
It's strange how the most devilish man of them all in the movie, Angel-Eyes, both has the most misleading name, and the most soothing thematic music in the movie. Just listen to the score when he comes riding up to that old farmstead right after Tuco busts out of that window in the beginning... Very strange one might think, but I can't help but think it was intentional, with a deeper purpose behind it all.

If the movie does indeed depict purgatory, Angel-Eyes is Lucifer himself. Of course he doesn't die at the end of the movie, we're just made to believe he does, but Blondie does beat him. That's how he and Tuco are able to escape with the gold.

By the way... Don't watch this movie in German or Spanish. It ruins the experience. The voices they use are completely boring, and have no feeling, no conviction. No passion! Clint Eastwood, famous from not just his acting and stonefaced appearance, but his rough voice too, sounds like some ordinary german guy. What a shame! And Tuco's quiet gibberings and excited breaths as he digs feverently for the gold before Blondie makes his re-appearance, those are completely gone in both dubs. What a shame...

...Speaking of which. Of course they're in purgatory by the way. :) *BOOM*, Blondie fires the cannon and sends Tuco tumbling head over heels, and bam - he rolls into a gravestone! He gets up all surprised, like he couldn't have seen all those thousands of graves before? This sudden transition that would just have seemed illogical in a lesser movie, but like I said - the place they're in isn't real. Things can happen there that cannot in the real world.

Therefore, it makes perfect sense. :)
 
Guden Oden said:
It's strange how the most devilish man of them all in the movie, Angel-Eyes, both has the most misleading name, and the most soothing thematic music in the movie. Just listen to the score when he comes riding up to that old farmstead right after Tuco busts out of that window in the beginning... Very strange one might think, but I can't help but think it was intentional, with a deeper purpose behind it all.
...

If you enjoy this aspect of the movie, and I cut your quote here mainly for size, you will probably enjoy High Plains Drifter as well. It's a must-see for those who enjoy westerns that go beyond the norm and try to stretch the genre into something deeper and more mysterious.

I like most of Eastwood's westerns. He just carries the roles so well that even if the story is not always exciting or even enjoyable, he, as a character, is a whole lotta fun to follow. The Terence Hill and Budd Spencer "Trinity" movies were also fun in their own way. Of course I should mention Lee Van Cleef in all of this. Like Jack Palance, he has a face and a demeanor that does something on film without the need for words. Ohh, the nostalgia.

Might have to pop in "The good, the bad, and the ugly," "(For) A Fistful of Dollars" or "For a Few Dollars More" one of these days. But if it doesn't have to be really old and classic, "Unforgiven" is also a top-notch movie.
 
Wow Guden, such a thoughful expose on what I considered to simply be 'a great movie'. The next time I watch it, I'll have to consider the themes you brought up.


Always loved the music (in fact I had the album and now the CD).
 
Back
Top