lock

[jvd]

I guess the lack of mouse or other similar precise control coming as standard is proof enough there won't be very advanced (if any) photo editing software in xbox360.
This arguing is getting ridiculous.

Your right it is getting riidculous.


But as for your point about mouse and precise input controlls as standard doesn't really hold up. The standard program can come with the ability to use the non standard device for better use on the more advanced features . A scanner isn't a standard feature of the pc yet photoshop has the option to get a picture from a scanner .



Personaly i believe that if ms wants the market place and player made items in games nad lvls to succeed they will need pretty robust tools to do this .They will need robust map editors , photo editors for textures and of course some type of modeler

 

[wco81]

Read his posts . He is the one suggesting that such a thing exists (Which it could or could not ) and makes the case that it has to be worse than the pc version at the tast . The discusion is not on if it exists or if it doesn't .

If the discussion is not on whether these tools will exist, then why do you say I suggested "such a thing exists?"

Here is my original sentence:

Why wouldn't you view or edit them on the PC itself, which is going to have better photo tools?

Yeah boy that's trolling right there because I'm really going out on a limb there.

 

[jvd]

Sigh , this is getting tiring

YOur post is this

If you load pics on your PC, why would you want to send the photos to the X360 again?

Why wouldn't you view or edit them on the PC itself, which is going to have better photo tools?

Or if you want to watch on TV, why not send it directly to the TV? Also, there are peripherals that connect a card reader to your S-video port. Or TVs with card reader slots built in.

In your post your assuming that these things exsit , why else would you give reasons against people using it if it didn't exist ? Or at the very least you are giving reasons why if it exists it wouldn't be used . I asked why you believe it has to be worse at the tast of photo editing than a pc . All you told me were programs all of which could be ported to the x360 and you never prove your point . You simply start trolling and giving comments that have nothing to do with the post .


You made the statement that the x360 version has to be worse than the pc version and never backed it up . What does the x360 lack that would make this program worse than a comparable program on the pc ? You failed to this you . You simply started trolling .

This thread is horribly off topic after your stating a "Fact" and not backing it up .

 

[wco81]

Do you see the question marks there?

I'm not stating anything as fact, although in the absence of any indication about any photo features beyond the ability to view them, it's a safe assumption (not a claim of fact) that a platform which has been used almost since the advent of digital photography itself is going to have better tools than a brand new platform.

I didn't really expect all this hair-splitting but I'm done with it.

Have at it.

 

[rabidrabbit]

jvd, as a mod pf this board, shouldn't you be stopping this kind of fruitless arguings instead of keeping them up forever.
I'm sure this topic is of little interest to anyone reading the forums.

 

[Sonic]

Stop rabidrabbit. There is no need for you to troll this topic only to add that comment. If you want to bring this up to jvd then do so by pming him.

 

[Bobbler]

Here is a better question: What makes you think there will be a photo editor?

There is no proof either way . However that is not what was being discussed. He is claiming that if there is one (As he claims that a fictional or real ) would be worse than what the pc offers and I disagree . We are not talking about if there will be one , as he never asks , he simplys states that the pc will simply be better at it .

You seem to require facts to back up the lack of one, how about some facts to back up the existance of one? Just like he can't prove the non existance, you can't prove the existance -- so what was the point of your posts? If you can't prove the opposite, then your points hold no water.

Once again you are argueing something you do not understand . Read his posts . He is the one suggesting that such a thing exists (Which it could or could not ) and makes the case that it has to be worse than the pc version at the tast . The discusion is not on if it exists or if it doesn't .

Actually, he said, and I quote:
"Why wouldn't you view or edit them on the PC itself, which is going to have better photo tools?"

That does not imply the xbox360 has them really. Its more taking a jab at the fact that it will most likely not have them. Why would you want to edit them on an xbox360, which probably can't, when you can just edit them on a PC? He was pointing at the fact that porting them to the X360 is like an intermediate step that is unnecessary -- you can edit and view them on a PC, why bother with doing it on an Xbox360 (I'm aware there are benefits of being able to see them on a huge screen, etc).

Correct me if I'm wrong, wco81.

I certainly didn't take that as saying they existed, much less that he was promoting that fact, maybe my english skills aren't up to snuff though!

Jvd, again, don't insinuate that I don't know the whole story.

 

[jvd]

jvd, as a mod pf this board, shouldn't you be stopping this kind of fruitless arguings instead of keeping them up forever.
I'm sure this topic is of little interest to anyone reading the forums.

Your right , i should have stoped the thread before people jumped on me for asking why he believes this to be afact . So i'm locking it not . If you believe it should be reopened then talk to sonic in pm about it