Just finished the game the other night.
I really liked it, but I'm not in love with it like everyone else. I liked the combat, the story, and art. However, I had a couple of negatives. One was the lack of enemy variety, especially the bosses. I wish there were more big fights in this game.
The other, and this may be a small thing but it really bothered me, was the climbing. I really hate climbing on highlighted ledges. It feels too much like busy work and its slow as hell. I hope they abandon that for the next installment.