And some people said they're not impressed?
Yeah I'm not saying it's a straight up PS5 game or something lol. Of course I expect a true next gen game designed with 10 TF, 16Gig ram spec to look world apart as it should be, but even if it's within the realm of what other games can achieve on current gen, Tlous still pushes the boat further with that much more foliage, world density, the crazy animation and the overall balance of the graphics output. I mean it's so hard to spot any short comings.It certainly looks very good. It doesn't look a generation apart though, it is in the realm of what other games do on current gen consoles.
People don't get impressed perhaps but it is impressive for being on weak hardware from 2013.
Imagine games created for 2020 hardware.
I can't, I just can't. And some people said they're not impressed?
https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/19233917/TLOUPII_DEMO_SCREEN_08.jpg
What's more impressive to you just curious?The only image I find mildly impressive from those is the first one. The two other don't look like something next gen to me. At least not in the same way the original The Last Of Us did when it was released for PS3.
I can't, I just can't. And some people said they're not impressed?
https://cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/19233917/TLOUPII_DEMO_SCREEN_08.jpg
What's more impressive to you just curious?
One more.
Shakes head...It's not a HDR capture.It looks nice but nothing mind blowing. Flat is how i describe the rendering not much I see going on. Indoors look a bit stale in lighting and it doesn't seem to have that HDR pop. It may be the artists going for a more muted tone. When i saw the molatov in one gameplay video the fire didn't look too good on the ground
Shakes head...It's not a HDR capture.
Cherry picking shots isn't a good way to evaluate an improvement of one game over another. There is a reason why DF does not cross compare games in this way.peaking of RDR2. Here's a snow comparison to illustrate how much Tlou's snow improves upon it.
It's overcast so yeah not shit the lighting would obviously look muted and flat compared to dusk or dawn lighting, their engine can certainly do more vibrant lighting with ease. And no you certainly can't tell how pop the HDR would look from SDR screenshots. HDR is not just about vibrant lighting, it's about showing the contrast, the level of detail or dynamic range in the darkest dark to the brightest highlight, you obviously have not played UC4, their HDR and lighting implementation is among the best.It's not that it's the lighting. Looks very muted/flat. You can look at games with great hdr and tell from screenshots the lighting will make the hdr pop. This looks very muted
But I'm not cherry picking? Played RDR2 for 40 hours and the snow area pretty much looked like that in the pic. Was only trying to find a pic with trees and snow on them for a closer comparison. The gameplay section from today's footage looked the same too.Cherry picking shots isn't a good way to evaluate an improvement of one game over another. There is a reason why DF does not cross compare games in this way.
You're likely to just cherry pick one that you think looks good and one you think looks bad without any understanding of the lighting tricks that could be going on.
You've compared in this case, a cut scene vs real gameplay in RDR2 and the most awkward shot of looking directly at the snow against trees and not factoring in how time of day is realtime and can change the lighting etc. You're looking for the shot that engages you the most and another the least. That's by default an improper comparison if you have to evaluate it like that; you're overlooking what you see is great with TLOU2 and being super critical of the things you don't want to look as good.
Give it some thought.
I get you are excited and love ND and TLOU2; and that's fine, so just leave it at that without trying to bias that enthusiasm against other titles.
you chose both images, one you couldn't generate and one you could. I'ts by definition cherry picking. If you want to evaluate RDR2 lighting and shading, evaluate RDR2 relative to what is missing and not missing. The quality of what they do in the game. There is a very particular DF on that technology by @DictatorBut I'm not cherry picking? Played RDR2 for 40 hours and the snow area pretty much looked like that in the pic. Was only trying to find a pic with trees and snow on them for a closer comparison. The gameplay section from today's footage looked the same too.