I mean it's nice that a phone would be powerful enough that you can plug it into a monitor and keyboard and keep using it.
That's the Continuum thing that MS talks about.
That would be a nice option if you're away from your home or your office, like at a hotel or something. That way, no need to take a laptop.
However, other than that situation, what advantage would there be to just use the phone at home or your office? You'd have to have a pretty powerful phone, not the $200 model. But if you can afford a flagship phone with the fastest SOCs, you're going to have laptops and a nice desktop in all likelihood. Or can afford such gear if you have a big need to do a lot of work requiring keyboard, mouse and a big monitor. And no matter how powerful the phone, a desktop or laptop from $500 and up is going to still have faster CPU, more RAM and more storage than any flagship phone.
Most people these days have a computer at their desk as well as their phones. So what problem would this Continuum phone exactly solve? Maybe not having to upgrade the PC as often? Sure but that's a trend that's hurting PC sales already.
This is probably one of the reasons Microsoft haven't pushed this really. One of the points would be a reduction in the number of computing devices you need to own and make space for to preferably a single one.
I guess if MS produces a Surface Phone with Continuum capabilities, that's more margin for them (than someone upgrading their Windows PC) and maybe it could gain some traction marketshare wise.
I think the people who would use just their phone for desktop tasks would be people wanting to do it just for the sake of doing it, not because they didn't have access to a good desktop or laptop.
Disagree. It was some 20 years ago that I realized that everything but the Big Iron molecular calculations I did could just as well be performed on a Palm Pilot. Lightweight databasing, Word processing, some small spreadsheets - nothing requiring much in the way of processing power. With image editing and gaming that shifted back a bit, but then again that pendulum has swung back to mobile devices in latter years due to improvements in processing power. Basically I use desktop computers out of habit, not need. An iPad Pro could theoretically do everything non-professional but run my Steam library of games. And if it had a decent way of handling RAW image editing and libraries, that "theoretically" would shift to an "in practise".
However, for some of my computing I simply
like using a big screen, keyboard and mouse.
Again, Continuum phones may be advantageous for people who travel a lot, though a lot of hotels would then have to offer displays and keyboard/mouse that they could plug into. Certainly a lot of hotel chains which cater to business travelers could do this. Typically they have little office space or "business centers" where they have printers and PCs that hotel guests can use. But business travelers may decide they rather still pack their laptops, just in case. Plus they could do work from their hotel rooms instead of going down to the business center. Better yet, a tablet which weighs 1.5 pounds or less might be a better choice to do some work as well as be handy for browsing or watching video content when not working.
You come up with some nice use cases on your own. ;-)
Personally, I've always preferred ultra portable + desktop to laptops. The desktop is the dinosaur. A large portion of the younger generation of computer users have never used a desktop computer at all. For many of those, having a means to drive peripherals from their phone would be an overall upgrade to the current compromise computer that a typical laptop constitutes. And a large portion of those work laptops I see docked to reasonable screens around the offices here would be replaced in an instant.
Market segmentation strategies makes this an awkward proposition for the large PC-interests, Apple have their own vision, and Android doesn't have a desktop software tradition. From a computing capability point of view though, the time is ripe for the concept to be tested.
Doesn't mean it will ever truly happen, Continuum seems dead in the water now, Apple is slowly moving in that direction but is reluctant as far as extensibility is concerned. We'll see what Android will support in the future. At present, unfortunately, the concept remains untested.